This holiday season, you probably have a long list of boozy holiday parties to attend. Many of which may consist of a Yankee Bottle Swap. For those not familiar, it’s the same thing as a White Elephant, but with alcohol. But this popular Christmastime party requires more thought than you might at first think.

That age old question of “What should I bring?” rings true in this case. After all, there’s an unlimited number of bottle options to choose from. Most hosts will set some sort of price limit or price floor depending on the guests. In a lot of cases it’s considered poor form to bring a bottle under $25 – and is certainly much more fun when the ante is upped.

That’s why we decided to ask the wine experts and co-owners of the Wine ConneXtion, Sam and Tina Messina, which bottles are your best bet for this year’s Yankee Bottle Swap. Here are 7 bottles to bring if you’re looking to impress your Yankee Swap friends.